I just scrolled past another "Holiday Top Toys" list. You know the one. It's plastered all over a big-box store's website, featuring a talking puppy, some kind of goo-filled monster, and the latest iteration of a building block set we've all seen a hundred times. And as a collector, and the owner of PopNya, I have to be honest: it feels like a total sham.
Those lists aren't about the "top toys." They're about the toys with the biggest marketing budgets. They're a reflection of what mega-corporations need to clear out of their warehouses before the end of the quarter. They're for parents in a panic, not for people who genuinely love toys as a medium of art and expression.
The toys on those lists are, for the most part, disposable. They have a six-month lifespan before they're forgotten, broken, or relegated to the bottom of a toy chest. Their value evaporates the second the plastic is torn off the cardboard.
That's not what a "top toy" is to me. Not even close.
For me, and for a massive, growing community of collectors, the real toys top toys list looks completely different. It's not found at Target or Walmart. It's found in specialized stores, online communities, and in the hearts of artists who pour their souls into small, vinyl figures. I'm talking about the world of designer toys.
A true top toy has an artist behind it. A name. A story. When I hold a MOLLY figure, I'm not just holding a piece of plastic. I'm holding a piece of Kenny Wong's legacy, an artist who has been evolving this character for over 15 years. It's the same with Kasing Lung's Labubu or Ayan Deng's Skullpanda. These aren't characters created by a marketing committee; they are extensions of an artist's vision. You can feel it in the sculpt, the expression, the whole vibe.
A top toy has a community. The feeling of walking into a store on release day is electric. I'll never forget my trip to the Pop Mart in NYC; the air was buzzing with collectors sharing their pulls, trading doubles, and celebrating when someone screamed because they found a secret. You don't get that in the doll aisle at a department store. You get tired-looking parents and crying kids. Our community is built on shared passion, the thrill of the hunt, and a genuine appreciation for the art.
And maybe most crucially, a top toy has the potential to become an investment. Not just emotionally, but financially. This is the part that truly separates our world from the mass market.
Let's take a concrete example. The MOLLY x Warner Bros. 100th Anniversary series. When it dropped, a blind box retailed for around $15. Fun, right? But certain figures immediately became standouts. The MOLLY dressed as Pennywise from "It" was an instant hit. I saw it being resold on collector forums and eBay for $40-$50 within days of release. The secret figure from that series, The Matrix MOLLY, was a whole other level. I personally saw confirmed sales of that figure for over $250.
Show me a talking puppy from a big-box store that can do that. It doesn't happen. The value of those toys only goes down. The value of a sought-after designer toy? It can explode. It's this dynamic that makes every unboxing a shot of adrenaline. You're not just opening a toy; you're revealing a potential treasure. If you've never experienced it, you can get a feel for the variety by browsing a proper MOLLY collection and seeing just how diverse and artistic the designs are.
But I need to be real with you. It's not all hype and skyrocketing values. Being a real collector means being critical and knowing when to call something out.
Honestly, the hype train can go off the rails. I've seen it happen. A few years back, there was a particular series from a major designer toy brand (I won't name the series to be polite, but veterans will know) that was promoted to the moon. The concept art was gorgeous, the marketing was relentless, and the community was chomping at the bit. Pre-orders sold out in minutes. But when the boxes started arriving... It was a mess.
I ordered two full cases for PopNya and for my personal collection. The paint application was sloppy on at least a third of the figures. Some had visible smudges, others had parts that didn't quite fit right. The plastic felt cheaper, lighter than their previous releases. On Reddit, the collector forums lit up with complaints. And the aftermarket reflected it. Within a month, people were trying to sell even the "rare" figures from the set for less than retail price just to get rid of them.
That's a lesson. Hype doesn't equal quality. A real "top toy" has to be well-made, first and foremost. This is why I always tell new collectors: don't just chase what's trending. Buy what you love, from a series with a reputation for quality.
Real Talk
If you're searching for top toy deals, you're approaching this from the wrong angle. This isn't about getting 30% off during a holiday sale. In the designer toy world, the "deal" is getting the chance to buy a popular series at its retail price before it sells out. The real deal is pulling a secret figure from a $15 box that's worth $150. The best deals aren't found on a coupon site; they're found by being part of the community, knowing what's about to drop, and acting fast. The discount-hunting mindset of mass-market toy buying just doesn't apply here. You're buying art, not just a product.
And the deeper you go, the more you learn the little secrets that separate the casual buyers from the true collectors.
Here's something you won't read in any mainstream toy review. The production runs matter. A lot. Often, the very first batch of a new series is the best one. I've seen this with my own eyes. Take the MOLLY "My Childhood" series. The first run had this beautiful, slightly soft, matte finish. The colors were perfect. When they did a restock about six months later to meet demand, the figures were noticeably glossier. The finish was different.
Is it a huge deal to a casual person? No. But to a dedicated collector, it's everything. The first-run figures are now considered more desirable. We look for subtle tells on the box, production date codes, slight variations in the packaging warnings, to identify them. It's this kind of detail, this "inside baseball," that makes collecting so rewarding. It's a language. It's a skill. You're not just buying; you're curating.
And this whole universe is so much bigger than just one company. While Pop Mart is undeniably the giant in the room, and you can learn a lot about the scene just by understanding what a Pop Mart store is, there are so many other incredible artists and studios.
Studios like Finding Unicorn are putting out lines like FARMER BOB and RiCO that are just stunning. The weight and texture of a FARMER BOB figure are unlike anything else. 52TOYS has their BeastBox and MegaBox lines, which are these intricate, transformable figures that are marvels of engineering. Then you have independent artists all over the world creating small-batch resin figures that are true works of art.
The "top toys" are not a monolith. It's a sprawling, diverse ecosystem of creativity.
So, how do you get started on this path? How do you find the real top toys?
First, forget the hype. Start by browsing. Look at different artists and series. Find a character or a style that genuinely speaks to you. Is it the sweet, whimsical nature of Dimoo? The edgy, high-fashion vibe of Skullpanda? The classic, pouting confidence of MOLLY? Your first purchase should be one you'd be happy to display even if it was worth a dollar.
Second, buy from trusted sources. That means the artist's own site, official brand stores like Pop Mart, or dedicated, reputable retailers like us here at PopNya. Be very, very careful with third-party sellers on Amazon or eBay, especially for new releases. The market is flooded with fakes, and they are getting scarily accurate. If a price seems too good to be true, it is.
Third, if you can, consider buying a full case (usually 12 unique boxes). It's a bigger upfront cost, but it's the only way to guarantee you get every regular figure in the series without any doubles. It also dramatically increases your odds of finding the secret or chase figure.
Finally, join the conversation. Get on the r/popmart subreddit. Find collector groups on Facebook or Discord. See what real people are unboxing. See their joy and their disappointment. You'll learn more from lurking in those communities for a week than you will from reading a dozen corporate-sponsored "top toys" lists.
So the next time you see one of those lists, just smile and know that you're in on a better secret. A secret world of art, community, and the pure, unadulterated thrill of the hunt. It's a much more interesting place to play, I can promise you that.
Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going back to watching for leaks of the next MOLLY series. The anticipation is half the fun.
Disclosure: PopNya may earn a commission if you purchase through links on this page.
