Let's be real for a second. The day "The Monsters Exciting Macaron" series dropped was pure, unadulterated chaos. I remember refreshing the Pop Mart site, my cart timing out, and then watching in horror as the entire stock evaporated in under two minutes. That was the moment the mini labubu keychain went from a cute accessory to a full-blown cultural phenomenon. And as someone who runs PopNya and has handled hundreds of these little guys, I can tell you: not all Labubu keychains are created equal.
The hype is centered around two main series: the original vinyl-faced "Exciting Macaron" and the newer, softer "Pin for Love." Customers ask me constantly which one is "better." The answer isn't simple. It depends on whether you're a hardcore collector, someone who just wants a cute bag charm, or if you're trying to avoid getting totally ripped off.
So, let's settle it. I'm pulling one of each from my personal collection and putting them head-to-head.
The OG King: The Monsters Exciting Macaron Series
This is the one that started it all. When people talk about the "Labubu keychain," they're usually picturing one of these. The series has a distinct design: a plush body with a smooth, matte vinyl face. The colors are iconic, Soymilk, Sesame, Lychee, Matcha, Taro. They have a certain weight and substance to them that feels… premium.
When I first got my hands on a case, the first thing I noticed was the contrast in textures. The plush is short and dense, and the vinyl face is cool and solid to the touch. The design is genius. Kasing Lung's character is perfectly captured in that slightly mischievous, toothy grin. The hardware, a sturdy lobster clasp, felt solid enough to actually use.
Then the market exploded.
Retail for a single blind box was around $16-$17. Within a week, the chase figure, "Toffee," was hitting $250+ on secondary markets. But the real shocker was a regular figure: Soymilk. It's just a simple, off-white Labubu. But its neutral, go-with-everything color made it the most sought-after regular in the set. I personally saw a Soymilk keychain, which had a 1-in-12 chance, sell for $120. That's a 600% markup for a non-secret figure. It was madness. This was the peak of the labubu keychain popmart frenzy.
Our Take (The Honest Truth about Macarons):
I love this series. It feels like a true collector's item. But I have to be brutally honest: they are terrible for actual, everyday use. I clipped a Lychee Pink to my tote bag for a week as a field test. The results were not pretty.
1. The Vinyl Face Scuffs. Easily. That beautiful matte vinyl? It shows every single nick and scratch. Tossing your keys in your bag means that vinyl face is getting scraped by metal, plastic, and whatever else is in there. 2. They Get DIRTY. Especially the light-colored ones like Soymilk and Sea Salt Coconut. The plush material is a magnet for dust and grime. And because of the vinyl face, you can't just toss it in the wash. Spot cleaning is your only option, and it's never quite the same. 3. The Price is Still Inflated. Even now, finding a Macaron series keychain for retail is tough. The demand is so high that resellers still command a premium, which can be frustrating for new collectors.
If you're a collector who plans to display them, the Macaron series is unbeatable. It's iconic. But if you want a daily companion for your backpack? You might want to think twice, unless you're okay with your $80 Soymilk looking like it crawled through a chimney.
The New Challenger: The Monsters Pin for Love Series
After the Macaron insanity, Pop Mart knew they had a hit. Their follow-up was "The Monsters Pin for Love" series. The concept is similar, a labubu keychain small enough to be a pendant, but the execution is totally different.
Instead of a vinyl face, the Pin for Love keychains are 100% plush. The facial features (eyes, mouth, teeth) are all intricately embroidered. The series also came with a small, matching enamel pin inside each box, hence the name. The plush itself feels different, too. It's softer, fluffier, and less dense than the Macaron series.
When I opened my first case for the store, the difference was immediate. They feel lighter and more like a traditional stuffed animal keychain. The embroidery is high-quality, giving them a crafty, handmade vibe. The colors are brighter and more whimsical, think bubblegum pinks and sky blues. The "pin" gimmick is cute, but honestly, most of my customers were just there for the Labubu.
The market reaction was strong, but not Macaron-level insane. The secret figure, "Love and Death," hit high prices, but the regular figures were more accessible. You could actually buy them without feeling like you were paying a car payment. It felt like Pop Mart learned a lesson and increased production to meet the demand for a pop mart mini labubu keychain.
Our Take (The Honest Truth about Pin for Love):
This series feels like Pop Mart's direct response to how people were actually using the Macaron keychains. They are, without a doubt, more practical.
1. More Durable for Daily Use. No vinyl face means no scuffing. The embroidered has are tough and won't get scratched off. You can be a little rougher with these. 2. Softer, Cuddlier Feel. If you like the squish factor, this is your series. They feel more like a tiny plushie and less like a structured collectible. 3. The Hardware is… Different.The clasp on the Pin for Love series is a slightly different style and, in my opinion, feels a tiny bit less substantial than the one on the Macaron series. It's not bad, but when you hold them side-by-side, you can feel the difference. It's a small cost-cutting measure, but a noticeable one for a collector.
The main downside? To some hardcore collectors, they feel a little less "special" than the Macarons. The vinyl face gave the originals a unique art toy feel. The Pin for Love series, while adorable, leans more towards a standard (albeit very high-quality) plush keychain.
Head-to-Head: The Ultimate Mini Labubu Keychain Showdown
| Feature | The Monsters Exciting Macaron | The Monsters Pin for Love | Winner | | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Material & Feel | Dense plush, solid vinyl face. Feels substantial and "art toy"-like. | Soft, fluffy all-plush body with embroidery. Feels like a traditional high-end plushie. | Macaron (for collectors), Pin for Love (for cuddliness) | | Durability | Low. The vinyl face is a scratch magnet. Light colors stain easily. Not ideal for bags or keys. | High. No vinyl to scuff. Embroidery is resilient. Can handle being on a backpack. | Pin for Love (by a landslide) | | Hardware | Very sturdy, classic lobster clasp with a quality feel. | Slightly lighter-weight clasp. Still functional, but feels a bit less premium than the OG. | Macaron | | Aesthetic | Iconic, minimalist, and almost "designer." The colors are more muted and chic. | Whimsical, cute, and colorful. The embroidered face is expressive and soft. | Tie (Purely subjective) | | Aftermarket Value | Extremely high. Even common figures can be 3-5x retail. A nightmare for budget collectors. | More reasonable. Secrets are expensive, but regulars are generally accessible near retail. | Pin for Love (for buyers), Macaron (for sellers) |
So, Which One Should You Actually Buy?
Look, my job is to sell these, but my passion is collecting them. So here's my real, unfiltered advice.
If you are a die-hard collector who wants the most iconic, sought-after piece to display on a shelf: You have to go for the Exciting Macaron series. It's the original, the one that defined the trend. It feels more like a piece of art. Just be prepared to pay the price, and for God's sake, don't put it on your keys. And be careful where you buy from; the high prices have led to a surge in fakes. I wrote a whole piece on this, so please read up on The Honest Guide to Buying a Labubu Keychain (Without Getting Scammed) before you drop $100 on an eBay listing.
If you want a cute Labubu to hang on your bag, use every day, and not have a panic attack if it gets bumped: Get the Pin for Love series. It's more durable, more affordable, and still incredibly cute. It's the practical choice. It's the one I'd give to a friend who's new to the hobby.
A note on other series: Don't forget there are other plush keychain series out there! The "Fall in Wild" series, for example, has some amazing designs like the Mushroom and Cactus. They have a similar all-plush feel to the Pin for Love series and are just as charming. The world of Labubu on Pop Mart is always expanding.
Ultimately, the "best" mini labubu keychain is the one that makes you happy. But understanding the real-world differences in material, durability, and market value is key to not feeling disappointed (or broke). The trend of dressing these little guys up is also huge right now, and the sizing can be tricky between series. If you're thinking of getting into that, it's worth checking out a guide on Labubu clothes and sizing to make sure you get the right fit.
For me, I have a special place in my heart for the Macarons. They represent a crazy moment in the designer toy world. But the Pin for Love that's been on my work bag for two months? It still looks brand new. And sometimes, that's what really matters.
Whatever you choose, the hunt is half the fun. We're always trying to get the latest drops and restocks in our own LABUBU collection, so you can always see what we've managed to snag. Happy hunting!
--- Disclosure: PopNya may earn a commission if you purchase through links on this page.
