I have a confession. My everyday tote bag has three keychains on it. And yes, all of them are CRYBABY. One is a vinyl, one is a plush, and one is a weird hybrid. It's a bit much, I know. But as someone who runs PopNya and handles these little guys all day, I consider it field research. And my research has led me to a definitive conclusion: not all crybaby keychains are created equal.
When you're thinking about getting a pop mart cry baby to hang on your keys or bag, you're really facing a choice between two completely different experiences. It's the great debate: the classic, sturdy vinyl versus the soft, cuddly crybaby plush. They look different, they feel different, and honestly, they live different lives once they're out of the box.
Let's get into it.
The Classic Vinyl: Your Tough Little Travel Companion
This is where it all started for most of us. The idea of taking the iconic 3-inch CRYBABY figures and shrinking them down into a portable crybaby pop mart keychain was genius. These are the ones you'll find in series like the iconic CRYBABY Crying Again Keychain collection.
When you get a crybaby mystery box for one of these, the experience is pure, classic Pop Mart. The little foil bag, the satisfying pop of the vinyl figure in your hand… it's the same thrill, just smaller. The first thing you notice is the detail. The sculpt is sharp, the paint is (usually) crisp, and every tiny tear and pout is perfectly preserved from its larger counterpart. This is the quintessential crying doll keychain.
I have the "Inflated" balloon boy from the Crying Again series on my work keys. It's been tossed in my purse, dropped on the pavement, and jangled against a dozen metal keys for months. And it looks… pretty good, actually. A few minor scuffs, sure, but the integrity is there. The vinyl is tough. It's designed to withstand the chaos of daily life. You can wipe it clean with a damp cloth if it gets grimy. It's a low-maintenance friend.
But it's not perfect. The hardware can be a mixed bag. On some older series, the clasp felt a little flimsy, and I've heard from customers who have had to replace the chain. Pop Mart seems to have improved this on recent releases, but it's something to be aware of. Also, while they are durable, a bad drop on concrete can cause paint chipping, especially on sharp corners or ears. It's a different kind of heartbreak.
And let's be real, while they're cute, they don't have that "comfort object" quality. They're hard plastic. They clink and clank. They're decorative armor for your bag, not a squishy friend to squeeze when you're stressed.
The Plush Revolution: Soft, Squishy, and High-Maintenance
Then came the crybaby plush keychain. This changed everything. Suddenly, our favorite sad character wasn't just a figure, but a soft, tactile companion. The first time I held the Powerpuff Girls collaboration cry baby keychain plush, I totally got it. It's just… so soft.
These plushies are a whole different vibe. They're often bigger than their vinyl counterparts, making more of a statement on a bag. They don't clank, they just sort of bob along silently. There's an undeniable comfort in reaching into your bag and feeling a soft little plush instead of hard plastic. It's why the crybaby plush category has exploded.
The details are translated through embroidery and different fabric textures. The tears might be made of a shiny, satin-like thread, and the hair from a fluffier material. It's a different kind of artistry. The cry baby plush from the Lonely Christmas series, for example, had little knitted scarves and hats. The level of detail can be incredible.
But here's the brutally honest part that other stores won't tell you. They get dirty. Oh my god, do they get dirty.
Especially the light-colored ones. I once put a beautiful, fluffy white cloud crybaby plush keychain on my black backpack. Within two weeks, it was a sad, dingy grey. The soft, porous fabric just soaks up dust, dirt, and dye transfer from your clothes and bags. You can't just wipe it clean. You have to perform a delicate surgical cleaning with a toothbrush and mild soap, praying you don't ruin the texture or make the colors bleed. It's a commitment.
I've also noticed that the facial expressions can sometimes get a little lost in the plush format. The precise, heartbreaking pout of a vinyl CRYBABY can become a slightly less defined embroidered line on a plush. It's still cute, but it can lose some of that sharp emotional punch that makes the character so compelling.
The Hybrid Anomaly: The "Crying for Love" Series
Just when we thought we had to choose, Pop Mart threw a curveball with the CRYBABY Crying for Love Series Vinyl Plush Hanging Card. I remember when we first got these in stock at PopNya. I opened one up (the "Love You Cherry Much" one, to be specific) and just stared at it for a minute.
It has the classic, perfectly sculpted vinyl head of a standard pop mart cry baby, but it's attached to a soft, bean-filled plush body. It's a franken-baby. And I'm still not sure how I feel about it.
On one hand, it solves my biggest issue with the full plushies: the face. You get that perfect, glossy, expressive vinyl face with all its emotional detail. But you also get the soft, squishy body. Best of both worlds, right?
Kinda. The texture clash is a little weird at first. Your fingers expect one thing and get two. But I will say, it's grown on me. The little plush body gives it a satisfying weight and dangle that a full vinyl keychain doesn't have. The crying for love popmart keychain is a really interesting experiment, and it shows that the designers are actively trying to innovate within the crybaby key chain format. It's a great option if you can't decide between the two styles.
Real Talk: A Collector & Seller's Verdict
Okay, so you're staring at the options, trying to decide. As someone who sees these every day, sells them, and collects them, here's my honest breakdown.
For daily, heavy-duty use on a set of keys or a frequently used bag, go with vinyl. The crybaby crying again keychain series is a workhorse. It will survive the apocalypse. It's the most practical choice. It's less of a collectible you're scared to damage and more of a companion that can actually handle your life.
If you want pure, unadulterated cuteness and a comfort object, get the plush. But please, for the love of all that is holy, be mindful of the color. If you're putting it on a dark-colored bag or a pair of jeans, maybe skip the white or pastel ones unless you enjoy the pain of watching them slowly fade to grey. Or, do what many of our customers do: use the crybaby plush keychain as a decoration for your room, hanging it from a shelf or pinboard where it can stay pristine.
If you're a die-hard collector who loves novelty, the vinyl/plush hybrids are for you. They're a unique piece of CRYBABY history and a conversation starter.
Honestly, my biggest warning is about the plushies. They are incredibly appealing, but you have to be realistic about their lifespan as a functional keychain. Think of them more like a delicate accessory, not a rugged piece of hardware. If you're looking to start your collection and want to see all the different styles in one place, you can browse CRYBABY figures and keychains on our site to compare them visually.
The Hunt: Secrets, Tricks, and Aftermarket Madness
Part of the fun is the chase, right? Most of these keychains, whether vinyl or plush, come in a crybaby mystery box. You don't know which one you're gonna get. This is where the collector brain kicks in.
Now, I have to address the age-old question: can you shake or weigh the boxes to find the one you want, or even the secret chase figure?
Real Talk Collector Tip: For the newer crybaby keychain popmart series? No. Just… no. I've handled hundreds, if not thousands, of these boxes at PopNya. Pop Mart has gotten incredibly good at standardizing the weights and packaging. The little plastic inserts, the desiccants, the figure itself, the weight differences are often less than a gram. The "shake test" is even more useless. You can't hear a difference. Anyone who tells you they have a foolproof method for a new series is probably just lucky or trying to sell you a "confirmed" box at a markup. Don't waste your time rattling boxes in a store. The thrill is in the surprise!
And the secondary market for these can get just as wild as the 3-inch figures. A regular cry baby key chain from a blind box might retail for around $13-$16. But a secret chase? I've seen the secret from the first pop mart crying again keychain series sell for over $75. It's smaller, but the rarity is the same. People are passionate about completing their crybaby series popmart collections, right down to the keychains.
It's a testament to how much this character resonates. It's more than just a crying doll keychain; it's a tiny piece of a larger artistic universe. The entire CRYBABY collection tells a story, and the keychains are like portable chapters.
So, whether you're a seasoned collector or just looking for your first cry baby keychain, the options are more varied and interesting than ever. It's not just about what it looks like, but how you want to bring that little piece of emotional art into your daily life. Do you want a tough little guardian who can handle the bumps and bruises, or a soft friend who needs a bit more care?
For me? I'll probably keep all three on my bag. It's a mess, but it feels right. Each one tells a different story.
--- Disclosure: PopNya may earn a commission if you purchase through links on this page.
